Season 1 is still the best season to my mind and practically 15 episodes of sheer televisual perfection. I don't even like to compare, so I'm just trying to concentrate on the stuff that makes me happy, like Shawn not being quite as much of a jerk, which helps when he's the hero.

I just want them to be writing the characters I fell in love with, and not just turning everything into a joke.

Yeah, I'm surprised by how little there is. I know Psych is a small fandom, but it has some great writers and Shassiet (hehehe) isn't exactly a great leap for the imagination. I can see all three pairing on the show. Surely the answer is a threesome.